PA EDitorial

Why Every Managing Editor Is Also a Relationship Builder

By Sivakani Jayaprakash, Managing Editor with PA EDitorial

A managing editor spends much of the day dealing with workflows, deadlines, reviewer invitations, decision letters, production queues, spreadsheets and editorial systems. Others might see the role as keeping processes moving, making sure manuscripts progress, reminders go out, decisions are recorded and system problems are resolved.

Anyone who has worked as a managing editor knows that processes are only part of the job. The other part is people. Every manuscript has an author behind it. Every review invitation reaches a researcher deciding whether to give up part of their time. Every editorial decision involves an editor. Every system issue eventually needs someone to explain what has happened and work with others to resolve it. Keeping a journal running is not simply about managing a workflow. It is about managing the relationships that make the workflow possible.

The Job Behind the Workflow

Editorial systems bring consistency to complex processes. They assign manuscripts, send reminders, record decisions and track reviews. They are essential to modern scholarly publishing, but they cannot capture everything around a manuscript.

A system can tell us that a reviewer has not responded to an invitation. It cannot tell us whether the reviewer overlooked the message, is travelling, is unusually busy or simply does not have the capacity to review at that moment. It can tell us that an editor has held a manuscript longer than expected, but not necessarily whether the editor needs a reminder, a clarification or simply more time. This is where the managing editor becomes more than someone who monitors a workflow. Experience teaches a managing editor when a standard process is enough and when a conversation is needed. A reminder may solve one problem, while a personal message may solve another. Knowing the difference is part of the job.

Consistency still matters, particularly in peer review. Processes work best when the people using them trust the people managing them.

Trust Is Built Over Time

Relationship building in editorial work rarely comes from one important conversation. More often, it develops through small interactions over months and years. It can be as simple as explaining why something is needed rather than sending a reminder with no context. It can mean recognising that a new editor may not yet understand a system, taking the time to answer a question or following up on something you promised to do. These actions rarely appear in an editorial report, but they influence how people experience the journal.

Managing editors also become a point of continuity. Editors change, authors move institutions, reviewers become unavailable and responsibilities shift. The managing editor may be one of the few people who understands the current process, why it exists and how it has evolved.

Sometimes Relationships Outlast the Role

There is one example from my own career that makes this particularly real for me. Before becoming a managing editor, I worked as a Journals Editorial Office (JEO) vendor manager supporting a publisher. My team was responsible for a portfolio of 1,362 journals. I was also assigned by the publisher as a JEO Assistant to one of those journals. As a leading international journal in business ethics, with a strong scholarly reputation, a substantial volume of submissions, numerous special issues and an extensive international network of editors, the journal required considerable editorial coordination and efficient management of its complex peer-review operations.

The journal invited me to attend its editorial board meetings and management conferences in the United States. This was unusual because JEO Assistants would not normally attend such meetings. Being included gave me an opportunity to understand the journal beyond its day-to-day workflow and build relationships with its editors. I left my vendor manager and JEO Assistant roles in 2019, and that same journal approached me about becoming its Managing Editor in 2023.

I often think about that connection because it shows something about relationships in editorial work that no workflow report can capture. At the time, I was simply doing the work in front of me, supporting the journal, working with its editors and helping things move forward. I had always made an effort to build a good working relationship with every editor rather than thinking about where that relationship might lead years later. Yet the connection remained.

This experience changed how I think about the role. The people we work with today are not simply names associated with a manuscript, an email or a task; they become part of our professional journey. The relationships we build can stay with us long after a particular role has ended.

The Hard Conversations Matter Too

Some of the most important relationships are built in difficult moments, when something has gone wrong: a reviewer has disappeared, an author is unhappy with a decision, an editor has not responded, a manuscript has been assigned incorrectly or a system problem has disrupted the workflow. A standard message may be part of the response, but it will not always be enough.

The managing editor first needs to understand what has happened, identify what can realistically be done and communicate that clearly. Sometimes a firm reminder is right; sometimes a call, an apology for an error or simply saying, ‘Let me check and come back to you’ is a better response. This requires judgement and credibility. People need to know that when a managing editor explains a process, there is a reason behind it. They also need to feel heard.

Relationships Make the Work Move

It’s easy to think of editorial work as a sequence of handovers: an author submits a manuscript; the journal sends it to an editor; the editor finds reviewers; the reviewers return their reports; and the editor makes a decision. The system records each stage, and the manuscript moves forward. In reality, the managing editor sits in the middle of a network of authors, editors, reviewers, publishing colleagues and other teams. The ability of people in that network to work together is what makes real progress possible.

A good relationship with an editor can make onboarding smoother: it’s easier to ask a question, raise a problem or chase a decision without every reminder feeling like a chase. With reviewers, it’s often about judgement: knowing when a short follow-up is helpful and when someone simply needs more time. If a system problem needs investigating, good contact with publishing and technical colleagues can help get to the right information and work out what has happened. With authors, a clear explanation early on can stop a small misunderstanding from turning into a long chain of emails. Managing editors are often measured by numbers, turnaround times, manuscript volumes, reviewer performance, acceptance rates and backlog. These measures are important, but they cannot show how many difficult conversations were handled constructively or how many misunderstandings were prevented. The next time you look at an editorial system and see a manuscript moving from one stage to another, it is worth remembering that the system is showing only part of the story. Behind that movement are people responding to messages, making decisions, asking questions, solving problems and relying on one another to keep the process moving.

As scholarly publishing becomes more automated and editorial systems become more sophisticated, the human side of the managing editor’s role may become even more important.

Systems may track the work, but relationships help the work happen.

About the Author

Sivakani Jayaprakash is a Managing Editor with PA EDitorial, providing peer-review management services for a range of journals. He has more than 20 years’ experience in scholarly publishing, including peer-review systems, editorial operations, research integrity and editorial strategy. In 2009, he pioneered one of India’s first peer-review teams, establishing a model for operational excellence that continues to influence the industry. Over the course of his career, he has built and scaled editorial teams and workflows across global journal portfolios.

7 thoughts on “Why Every Managing Editor Is Also a Relationship Builder”

  1. Dr. E. Aravinraj

    A very insightful and well-articulated perspective!

    Scholarly publishing is not just about managing manuscripts, deadlines, and editorial workflows; it is equally about building trust, maintaining meaningful professional relationships, and understanding the people behind every process. The emphasis on human judgement, empathy, and communication highlights the true value of a managing editor. Indeed, while systems facilitate the workflow, it is relationships that sustain the scholarly publishing ecosystem.

    Excellent write-up, Sivakani Jayaprakash!

  2. A wonderful read! Having spent years in scholarly publishing, I can truly relate to the importance of relationships behind every editorial workflow. Systems and processes keep things organised, but it is the trust, experience and relationships we build with people that make a lasting difference. Thank you for sharing these valuable insights!

  3. Balaji Kathiravan

    A very insightful perspective! Managing editorial workflows is not just about meeting deadlines and tracking manuscripts; it’s equally about building trust, maintaining relationships, and communicating effectively with authors, reviewers, and editors. A reminder that strong relationships are the foundation of successful scholarly publishing. Well written!

  4. Saranya Tamilmani

    Such an honest and insightful perspective! I could genuinely relate to so much of what you have shared. It is wonderful to see the realities of our roles as managing editors articulated with such openness and clarity, particularly from someone with such extensive experience in the publishing world.

    Thank you for sharing your experiences so thoughtfully. Truly a meaningful read!

  5. Dr. Shounak Biswas

    Beautifully articulated! It’s easy to get caught up in processes and deadlines, but at the heart of editorial work are the people and relationships that make everything possible. Loved the thought that systems may track the work, but relationships make it happen. A wonderful read!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *